Skip to content

Coffee & Sweets

Missy Kay's Sweet Shoppe

A family-run sweet shop (Cody and Allison Neidert’s) on the corner of Main and 5th Streets, marked by its pink door. Cookies are baked fresh in the shop (chocolate chip, peanut butter, M&M, snickerdoodle, and bulk orders by arrangement), the soda cooler runs past 60 varieties, and the shelves mix candy from the classic to the hard-to-find with novelty popsicles, toys, greeting cards, Colorado honey and fudge from What The Fudge in Eaton.

The shop calls itself “The Sweetest Place in NoCo.” Posted hours are 10 to 6 on weekdays, later on Friday and Saturday nights, and the shop notes they can shift with business and weather.

At a glance cookies · candy · soda · gifts · kids

← Eat & drink

Checked November 10, 2026 against missykays.com. Hours and phone numbers change fastest, so the business’s own page is the record. Report a correction

Own or run Missy Kay's Sweet Shoppe? Send a photo, new hours or a correction. Listings are editorial and free; how listings work.

In the guides

Read about Missy Kay's Sweet Shoppe

All guides →
  • Explore Windsor: five places in walking order

    The lake and Boardwalk Park first, then the 1909 town hall and the Main Street blocks, with Main Park at the end. Four stops from one parking spot. The river trail is a drive away, if there is time.

More in Windsor

Eat & drink

All eat & drink →

What’s on in Windsor, every Thursday

One email a week, every Thursday: the weekend’s events, the scores, places that opened or closed in Windsor, and a new article when there is one. Next issue Thursday, November 19 at 7 am.

Which towns?
Show all towns

Free. One email a week. Unsubscribe any time. We don’t sell your email address or share it for advertising. Our service providers (Buttondown for the newsletter, Formspree for forms) process it only to deliver the newsletter or handle your submission. See the privacy page. Read last Thursday’s issue.